Since I actually forgot that it was Subaru that choose Patrasche's Name, I gave some thought as to what Fembaru would pick. Here, you can give your takes (Tick 'Always Tick' and any you would be fine with)

Question

score 15 · Answer 1

Always Tick (So I can see number of responderds)

score 15 · Answer 2

Patrasche (Dog of Flanders, pretty pessimistic, though I don't see why this Subaru wouldn't have grown up and enjoyed the same anime adaptation of the novel)

score 5 · Answer 3

Silver (Being a dirty unwashed westaboo, Subaru might think of the Lone Ranger's horse as a good inspiration 'Heigh Ho Silver! Away!')

score 5 · Answer 4

Samwise (Same reasoning as Patrasche since he's an embodiment of loyalty, but more of a filthy westaboo pick)

score 3 · Answer 5

Klepacki (Last name of a composer from whom Subaru has an entire album already referenced on her phone)

score 2 · Answer 6

Obsidian (Silver as inspiration, but more fitting)

score 2 · Answer 7

Gamgee (Samwise's last name, so same as that, but with different flavour)

score 0 · Answer 8

Dark Silver (Same as Silver but added 'Dark' to acknowledge her actual colour)